From 28c8d107be3f8807ceae1a94d9ba1097f317f146 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Your Date: Mon, 6 Jul 2026 18:45:14 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?docs(investigations):=20#636=20=C2=A71=20verify?= =?UTF-8?q?=20=E2=80=94=20Fallacies=20EN/RU=20SVGs=20already=20current=20(?= =?UTF-8?q?#664),=20no=20r=C3=A9g=C3=A9n=20needed?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Executes dispatch `x0ykyn` TERTIAIRE [3] (#636 §1) as a read-only verification. The dispatch asked for a manifest of Fallacies EN/RU régénération scope (PKs/nodes changed in the taxonomy CSV since the committed SVGs). Code=truth shows the premise is moot: the SVGs were regenerated 2026-07-03 by #664 (commit d4484679, merged by ai-01), and ZERO commits touch the Fallacies taxonomy CSV after that date. The "~34 commits stale / dated 06-04" wording restated in ai-01's 2026-07-06 #636 comment predates #664 (it quotes #636's original opening title verbatim). Proof (all in the doc): - `git log -1 -- ` = d4484679 2026-07-03 (#664 "refresh Fallacies EN/RU"). - `git log d4484679..HEAD -- ` = empty (0 commits since the régén). - Last CSV commit before régén = 2079f0cc 2026-07-02 (#640); régén is one day later (strictly newer). - #664 body (ai-01-authored): stale labels purged (All-or-Nothing Thinking etc.), fresh labels present (Abusive relativism etc.), RU 1447 Cyrillic nodes. - Spot-check: `grep -c "All-or-Nothing Thinking" en/Fallacies_en.content.svg` = 0 (stale label gone). Conclusion: gap #1 (#636 §1) is already CLOSED. No manifest of pending changes exists because there are none. Recommendation: close #636 entirely (§1 closed by #664 2026-07-03, §2 closed by #724 2026-07-06 — both gaps in the title resolved). Read-only: 0 write Cards/, 0 régén, 0 CSV/DB/OWL mutation, 0 rendering code. git log / git show / gh pr view / one grep on a committed SVG only. Dispatch x0ykyn TERTIAIRE [3] / #636 §1. Base 240511c8. Co-authored-by: Claude-Code --- ...-06-fallacies-enru-svg-freshness-verify.md | 88 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 88 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/investigations/2026-07-06-fallacies-enru-svg-freshness-verify.md diff --git a/docs/investigations/2026-07-06-fallacies-enru-svg-freshness-verify.md b/docs/investigations/2026-07-06-fallacies-enru-svg-freshness-verify.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5f405604 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/investigations/2026-07-06-fallacies-enru-svg-freshness-verify.md @@ -0,0 +1,88 @@ +# Fallacies EN/RU mindmap SVG — freshness verification (read-only) + +**Date:** 2026-07-06 · **Author:** po-2024 · **Dispatch:** `x0ykyn` TERTIAIRE [3] / #636 §1 +**Scope:** read-only investigation — 0 write `Cards/`, 0 régén, 0 CSV/DB/OWL mutation. + +## TL;DR — gap #1 (#636 §1) is already CLOSED + +The Fallacies EN/RU mindmap SVGs are **current as of 2026-07-03** (commit `d4484679`, PR #664, +merged by ai-01). **Zero commits touch the Fallacies taxonomy CSV after that date.** The +"~34 commits stale" premise in #636's title (and restated in ai-01's 2026-07-06 #636 comment) +was true when #636 was opened, but was resolved by #664 three days before that comment. **No +regeneration is needed; no manifest of pending changes exists because there are none.** + +This document is the code=truth verification of that closure. + +## What was asked + +Dispatch `x0ykyn` TERTIAIRE [3] (#636 §1): produce a read-only manifest of the Fallacies EN/RU +régénération — list the PKs/nodes actually changed in the taxonomy CSV since the committed SVGs +(then dated 2026-04-06), to scope a turnkey régén for the FreeMind side. + +## What code=truth shows + +### 1. The SVGs were regenerated 2026-07-03, not left at 2026-04-06 + +``` +$ git log -1 --format="%h %ai %s" -- Cards/Fallacies/Mindmaps/en/Fallacies_en.content.svg +d4484679 2026-07-03 15:42:45 +0200 fix(mindmap): #636 refresh Fallacies EN/RU mindmap SVGs to current taxonomy (#664) +``` + +Same commit `d4484679` for all four artifacts: +- `Cards/Fallacies/Mindmaps/en/Fallacies_en.content.svg` +- `Cards/Fallacies/Mindmaps/en/Fallacies_en.links.svg` +- `Cards/Fallacies/Mindmaps/ru/Fallacies_ru.content.svg` +- `Cards/Fallacies/Mindmaps/ru/Fallacies_ru.links.svg` + +PR #664 title: *"fix(mindmap): #636 §1 — refresh Fallacies EN/RU mindmap SVGs"* — merged +`2026-07-03T13:42:45Z`, author ai-01. + +### 2. Zero commits on the taxonomy CSV since the régén + +``` +$ git log --oneline d4484679..HEAD -- "Cards/Fallacies/Argumentum Fallacies - Taxonomy.csv" +(empty — 0 commits) +``` + +The last commit touching the Fallacies taxonomy CSV before the régén was `2079f0cc` +(2026-07-02, PR #640). The régén (`d4484679`, 2026-07-03) is **one day later** — the SVGs are +strictly newer than the CSV they render. + +### 3. #664's own scope proof (authoritative, authored by ai-01) + +The PR #664 body documents the freshness delta against the 2026-04-06 baseline (`55c6774e`): + +- **Stale labels purged** (absent from current CSV, were in the old SVG): + `All-or-Nothing Thinking`, `Appeal to desperation`, `Appeal to outrage`. +- **Fresh labels present** (in current CSV, now in the regenerated SVG): + `Abusive relativism`, `Appeal to custom`, `Appeal to moral elevation`, `Appeal to pragmatic urgency`. +- **RU refreshed** with 1447 Cyrillic text nodes (`Софизмы`, `Обструкция`…). + +Spot-check (this investigation): `grep -c "All-or-Nothing Thinking" …/en/Fallacies_en.content.svg` +→ **0** — confirms the stale label is gone from the committed EN SVG. + +## Conclusion + +| Question | Answer | +|----------|--------| +| Are the Fallacies EN/RU SVGs stale relative to the CSV? | **No.** SVGs 2026-07-03 ≥ last CSV commit 2026-07-02. | +| How many CSV commits pending a régén? | **0** (`git log d4484679..HEAD -- ` empty). | +| Does #636 §1 still need work? | **No.** Closed by #664 (2026-07-03). | +| Should a régén be scheduled? | **No.** Nothing to catch up to. | + +## Recommendation + +**Close #636 entirely.** §2 (Virtues clones) was resolved separately on 2026-07-06 by #724 +(ai-01 — 8/8 languages localized). §1 (Fallacies EN/RU stale) was resolved 2026-07-03 by #664. +Both gaps named in #636's title are now closed; the issue can be closed. + +The "~34 commits stale / dated 06-04" wording in ai-01's 2026-07-06 #636 comment appears to +predate #664 (it restates #636's original opening premise verbatim). This is not a live +regression — #664 is on master and the CSV has not moved since. + +## Non-goals (respectés) + +- 0 write under `Cards/`. 0 production / rendering code change. 0 CSV/DB/OWL mutation. 0 régén. +- Read-only: `git log`, `git show`, `gh pr view`, one `grep` on a committed SVG. + +Relates: #636, #664, #724, dispatch `x0ykyn` TERTIAIRE [3].