diff --git a/app/services/duplicate_profile_checker.rb b/app/services/duplicate_profile_checker.rb
index d8136d4ea22..06c6e028f7b 100644
--- a/app/services/duplicate_profile_checker.rb
+++ b/app/services/duplicate_profile_checker.rb
@@ -16,8 +16,10 @@ def check_for_duplicate_profiles
 
     pii = cacher.fetch(profile.id)
     duplicate_ssn_finder = Idv::DuplicateSsnFinder.new(user:, ssn: pii[:ssn])
-    associated_profiles = duplicate_ssn_finder.associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn
-    if !duplicate_ssn_finder.ial2_profile_ssn_is_unique?
+    associated_profiles = duplicate_ssn_finder.duplicate_facial_match_profiles(
+      service_provider: sp.issuer,
+    )
+    if associated_profiles
       ids = associated_profiles.map(&:id)
       user_session[:duplicate_profile_ids] = ids
     end
diff --git a/app/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder.rb b/app/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder.rb
index 09577302584..1b75f323f43 100644
--- a/app/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder.rb
+++ b/app/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder.rb
@@ -13,14 +13,16 @@ def ssn_is_unique?
       Profile.where(ssn_signature: ssn_signatures).where.not(user_id: user.id).empty?
     end
 
-    def associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn
-      Profile.active.facial_match.where(ssn_signature: ssn_signatures)
-        .where(initiating_service_provider_issuer: sp_eligible_for_one_account)
+    def duplicate_facial_match_profiles(service_provider:)
+      Profile
+        .active
+        .facial_match
+        .where(ssn_signature: ssn_signatures)
+        .joins('INNER JOIN identities ON identities.user_id = profiles.user_id')
+        .where(identities: { service_provider: service_provider })
+        .where(identities: { deleted_at: nil })
         .where.not(user_id: user.id)
-    end
-
-    def ial2_profile_ssn_is_unique?
-      associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn.empty?
+        .distinct
     end
 
     # Due to potentially inconsistent normalization of stored SSNs in the past, we must check:
diff --git a/spec/services/duplicate_profile_checker_spec.rb b/spec/services/duplicate_profile_checker_spec.rb
index b037f2a08a2..2ba069741df 100644
--- a/spec/services/duplicate_profile_checker_spec.rb
+++ b/spec/services/duplicate_profile_checker_spec.rb
@@ -48,6 +48,13 @@
 
         context 'when user has accounts with matching profile' do
           let(:user2) { create(:user, :fully_registered) }
+          let!(:user2_identity) do
+            create(
+              :service_provider_identity,
+              user: user2,
+              service_provider: sp.issuer,
+            )
+          end
           let!(:profile2) do
             profile = create(
               :profile,
diff --git a/spec/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder_spec.rb b/spec/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder_spec.rb
index 5f8000068ae..26afcbeacd9 100644
--- a/spec/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder_spec.rb
+++ b/spec/services/idv/duplicate_ssn_finder_spec.rb
@@ -7,11 +7,6 @@
 
     subject { described_class.new(ssn: ssn, user: user) }
 
-    before do
-      allow(IdentityConfig.store).to receive(:eligible_one_account_providers)
-        .and_return([OidcAuthHelper::OIDC_FACIAL_MATCH_ISSUER])
-    end
-
     context 'when the ssn is unique' do
       it { expect(subject.ssn_is_unique?).to eq(true) }
     end
@@ -68,79 +63,86 @@
     end
   end
 
-  describe '#associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn' do
+  describe '#duplicate_facial_match_profiles' do
+    let(:service_provider) { OidcAuthHelper::OIDC_FACIAL_MATCH_ISSUER }
+    let(:other_service_provider) { OidcAuthHelper::OIDC_FACIAL_MATCH_ISSUER }
     let(:ssn) { '123-45-6789' }
     let(:user) { create(:user) }
+    let(:other_user) { create(:user) }
+    let(:profile) do
+      create(
+        :profile,
+        idv_level: :unsupervised_with_selfie,
+        pii: { ssn: ssn },
+        user: user,
+        active: true,
+      )
+    end
+    let!(:identity) do
+      create(
+        :service_provider_identity,
+        service_provider: service_provider,
+        user: user,
+      )
+    end
+    let(:other_profile_idv_level) { :unsupervised_with_selfie }
+    let(:other_profile_ssn) { ssn }
+    let(:other_profile_active) { true }
+    let!(:other_profile) do
+      create(
+        :profile,
+        idv_level: other_profile_idv_level,
+        pii: { ssn: other_profile_ssn },
+        user: other_user,
+        active: other_profile_active,
+      )
+    end
+    let!(:other_identity) do
+      create(
+        :service_provider_identity,
+        service_provider: other_service_provider,
+        user: other_user,
+      )
+    end
 
     subject { described_class.new(ssn: ssn, user: user) }
 
-    before do
-      allow(IdentityConfig.store).to receive(:eligible_one_account_providers)
-        .and_return([OidcAuthHelper::OIDC_FACIAL_MATCH_ISSUER])
+    context 'when the other profile is active, has matching SSN and is at facial match IDV level' do
+      it 'returns list with matching profile' do
+        expect(subject.duplicate_facial_match_profiles(service_provider:).last.id)
+          .to eq(other_profile.id)
+      end
     end
 
-    context 'when profile is IAL2' do
-      context 'when ssn is taken by different profile by and is IAL2' do
-        it 'returns list different profile' do
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, user: user, active: true)
+    context 'when the other profile is not at facial match IDV level' do
+      let(:other_profile_idv_level) { :legacy_unsupervised }
 
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, active: true)
-          expect(subject.associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn.size).to eq(1)
-        end
+      it 'is empty' do
+        expect(subject.duplicate_facial_match_profiles(service_provider:)).to be_empty
       end
+    end
 
-      context 'when ssn is taken by different profile by and is not IAL2' do
-        it 'returns empty array' do
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, user: user, active: true)
-
-          create(:profile, pii: { ssn: ssn }, active: true)
-          expect(subject.associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn.size).to eq(0)
-        end
-      end
+    context 'when the other profile has a different SSN' do
+      let(:other_profile_ssn) { '555-66-7788' }
 
-      context 'when ssn is not taken by other profiles' do
-        it 'returns empty array' do
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, user: user, active: true)
-          expect(subject.associated_facial_match_profiles_with_ssn.size).to eq(0)
-        end
+      it 'is empty' do
+        expect(subject.duplicate_facial_match_profiles(service_provider:)).to be_empty
       end
     end
-  end
 
-  describe '#ial2_profile_ssn_is_unique?' do
-    let(:ssn) { '123-45-6789' }
-    let(:user) { create(:user) }
-
-    subject { described_class.new(ssn: ssn, user: user) }
+    context 'when the other profile is not active' do
+      let(:other_profile_active) { false }
 
-    before do
-      allow(IdentityConfig.store).to receive(:eligible_one_account_providers)
-        .and_return([OidcAuthHelper::OIDC_FACIAL_MATCH_ISSUER])
-    end
-    context 'when profile is IAL2' do
-      context 'when ssn is taken by different profile by and is IAL2' do
-        it 'returns false' do
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, user: user, active: true)
-
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, active: true)
-          expect(subject.ial2_profile_ssn_is_unique?).to eq false
-        end
+      it 'is empty' do
+        expect(subject.duplicate_facial_match_profiles(service_provider:)).to be_empty
       end
+    end
 
-      context 'when ssn is taken by different profile by and is not IAL2' do
-        it 'returns true' do
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, user: user, active: true)
-
-          create(:profile, pii: { ssn: ssn }, active: true)
-          expect(subject.ial2_profile_ssn_is_unique?).to eq true
-        end
-      end
+    context 'when the other profile has not been active with the service_provider' do
+      let(:other_service_provider) { OidcAuthHelper::OIDC_ISSUER }
 
-      context 'when ssn is not taken by other profiles' do
-        it 'returns true' do
-          create(:profile, :facial_match_proof, pii: { ssn: ssn }, user: user, active: true)
-          expect(subject.ial2_profile_ssn_is_unique?).to eq true
-        end
+      it 'is empty' do
+        expect(subject.duplicate_facial_match_profiles(service_provider:)).to be_empty
       end
     end
   end